An argument against zoos as educational institutions

A child fell into an enclosure with a gorilla named Harambeand to protect the child the gorilla was shot. Dozens and dozens of articles have poured over the minutia of the events already.

An argument against zoos as educational institutions

Share via Email The rare tuatara was once common across New Zealand but was reduced to surviving only on some small islands. Captive breeding programs are restoring this unusual animal back to former numbers and distributions. I also spent a number of years working as a volunteer keeper at two zoos in the U.

However, I am perfectly willing to recognise that there are bad zoos and bad individual exhibits. Not all animals are kept perfectly, much as I wish it were otherwise, and even in the best examples, there is still be room for improvement. But just as the fact that some police are corrupt does not mean we should not have people to enforce the law, although bad zoos or exhibits persist does not mean they are not worthwhile institutes.

Against Zoos, by Dale Jamieson

It merely means we need to pay more attention to the bad and improve them or close them. In either case, zoos at least in the U. While a bad collection should not be ignored, if you are worried the care and treatment of animals in captivity I can point to a great many farms, breeders, dealers and private owners who are in far greater need or inspection, improvement or both.

But at what point does that become captivity? A m fence? What if veterinary care is provided or extra food as in many reserves or as part of conservation projects. What I would state with absolute confidence is that for many species but no, not all it is perfectly possible to keep them in a zoo or wildlife park and for them to have a quality of life as high or higher than in the wild.

They can be spared bullying or social ostracism or even infanticide by others of their kind, or a lack of a suitable home or environment in which to live. So a good zoo will provide great care and protection to animals in their care. These are good things for the individuals concerned, but what do zoos actually bring to the table for the visitors and the wider world?

This is, naturally, what I want to focus on, but it is I hope worth having dealt with the more obvious objections and misapprehensions. One of only a few hundred Sumatran tigers left in the world, this individual is part of a captive breeding program that is linked to conservation efforts - protecting wild areas and reintroducing animals to them.

Moreover, some of these collapses have been sudden, dramatic and unexpected or were simply discovered very late in the day.

Zoos protect against a species going extinct. A species protected in captivity provides a reservoir population against a population crash or extinction in the wild. Here they are relatively safe and can be bred up to provide foundation populations.

A good number of species only exist in captivity and still more only exist in the wild because they have been reintroduced from zoos, or the wild populations have been boosted by captive bred animals. Quite simply without these efforts there would be fewer species alive today and ecosystems and the world as a whole would be poorer for it.

Although reintroduction successes are few and far between, the numbers are increasing and the very fact that species have been saved or reintroduced as a result of captive breeding shows their value.

Big Issues

Many children and adults, especially those in cities will never see a wild animal beyond a fox or pigeon, let alone a lion or giraffe. Sure television documentaries get ever more detailed and impressive, and lots of natural history specimens are on display in museums, but that really does pale next to seeing a living creature in the flesh, hearing it, smelling it, watching what it does and having the time to absorb details.The argument for zoos is often that they serve to educate the public, they give people who can’t afford to travel a chance to see the animals, and that zoos serve as important conservation centers.

Zoos protect against a species going extinct. A species protected in captivity provides a reservoir population against a population crash or extinction in the wild.

An argument against zoos as educational institutions

Zoos, pseudo-sanctuaries, marine parks, traveling zoos, roadside zoos, and other similar attractions imprison animals who long to be free. Learn more about how you can help animals.

While zoos claim that they are "conserving" wildlife both for the sake of the wild animals and for society's education, at the heart of these exhibitions, animals are held captive primarily for our entertainment. Meanwhile, in a case-to-case perspective, we are doing these animals more harm than good. As with any argument there is a positive. The positive part about zoos and animal bonding is the small sectors of zoos that offer wildlife safari parks. The San Diego wildlife safari and the Henry Doorly Zoo located in Omaha Nebraska, are just a few. Against Zoos. by Dale Jamieson. In PETER SINGER Despite the pious platitudes that are often uttered about the educational efforts of zoos, however, there is little evidence that zoos are very successful in educating people about animals. Some of these animals are sold and wind up in the hands of individuals and institutions which lack.

Zoos allow humans to connect and learn about animals through a personal level.F or an example to outline the good of zoos, I will be using the Saint Louis Zoo as well as other institutions. 1. Many children, as well as adults, visit zoos through field trips formal classes, workshops, tours, outreach programs, camps, lectures etc.

Zoos are not educational. Zoos operate on the premise that they provide an opportunity for the public to learn about animals.

An argument against zoos as educational institutions

However, this is untrue, as keeping animals in confined and unnatural environments tend to alter their natural behavior, character, and responses. Zoos are are valuable for public education, awareness, and scientific research.

Zoos allow humans to connect and learn about animals through a personal level.F or an example to outline the good of zoos, I will be using the Saint Louis Zoo as well as other institutions.

Essay: Negative effects of animal zoos and confinement – SchoolWorkHelper